Poor Plight of RTI in Uttar Pradesh : cases being heard without any consideration to documents on record

In UPSIC , cases are being heard without giving any consideration to the documents / papers on record ( File of the case ) . The situation attains more gravity because one such  case  was heard by none other than the UP CIC Ranjit Singh Pankaj . In  hearing dated 23-11-10 of case no. S1-1460/C/10  Km. Aishwarya Sharma Vs. PIO office of CM UP ,  The PIO Dr. Nand Lal lied that the matter was related to nagar nigam Lucknow and the same has been transferred to Lucknow nagar nigam . The fact was that the matter was related to office of CM UP only as little Aishwarya had shot this RTI to search her letter that was lost in CM office . The CIC of UP didn't bother to have a look at the letter of section 6 of little Aishwarya and blindly believed what the PIO uttered. The case was disposed off by the order dated 23-11-10 which is available at given link- http://file1.hpage.com/002161/04/bilder/s1-1460-c-2010_order_dtd_23_11_10.jpg I always wonder how a person holding a post of the stature  of " ELECTION COMMISSIONER of INDIA " can behave so arbitrarily ? But with Sycophants of power being appointed as info-commissioners , how can I expect any law-abiding behaviour so need of the hour is to revamp the appointment process of info-commissioners and make it transparant and participatory. -- Urvashi Sharma RTI Helpmail( Web Based ) aishwaryaj2010@gmail.com Mobile Rti Helpline 8081898081 ( 8 A.M. to 10 P.M. )